As charter schools lobby the State House for increased funding for building
improvements, they have a new tool to help them make their case: A report expected
to be released Monday outlines the financial challenges faced by Massachusetts charter
schools that lease or purchase their own facilities.
According to the study, published by two charter school advocacy groups,
Massachusetts charter schools spend an average of $1,235 per student on facilities —
$342 more than what they are provided by the state. To bridge that gap, charter
schools must tap into their education budgets, using an average of 3 percent of funds
that could otherwise go toward classroom learning.
Charter school supporters are hoping the new research will buoy calls for their schools
to receive a bigger piece of the state budget pie — despite concerns that a funding
increase might divert resources from public schools
“Charter school students should have the same amount of money paid for their
education as their peers in the community,” said Marc Kenen, executive director of the
Massachusetts Charter Public School Association , which did not write the report but
is helping to publish it. “We’re hoping that the Legislature will see that charter
students are getting the short end of the stick.”
Charter schools currently must find a way to pay for their facilities through a mix of
public and private funding.
Metro
For subscriber only stories, photos, videos and events, visit the Insiders page.The issue of how to finance charter school
facilities has come to a head as charter schools
have grown in popularity. In recent weeks,
charter school advocates have encouraged
legislators to abolish a stateimposed cap on
the number of charter schools allowed to
operate in lowperforming school districts.
According to the study, 78 percent of the
state’s charter schools plan to increase
enrollment by 2016. Most will need more
classrooms and bigger buildings.
The 19page study, conducted by the Colorado League of Charter Schools and the
National Alliance for Public Charter Schools, was the product of indepth surveys sent
to the state’s 68 charter schools, 90 percent of which responded.
It gives the most detailed picture yet of the physical size of the state’s charter schools
and sums they pay to lease or purchase buildings. The study recommended increasing
the perpupil facilities allowance, as well as mandating that charter schools have first
access to buying unused public schools.
“More equitable facilities funding would allow public charter schools to allocate more
operational dollars toward core educational items and enhance their ability to provide
a wellrounded educational experience,” the report stated.
The Colorado League of Charter Schools and the National Alliance for Public Charter
Schools have conducted similar surveys in Colorado and a handful of other states,
including Texas, Georgia, New York, and New Jersey.
Other education advocates said they are wary of charter schools’ demands for
increased funding. Tom Scott, executive director of the Massachusetts Association of
School Superintendents, said he is concerned that the limited pool of education
funding could be drained by charter schools.
“The model of taking students from multiple grades, multiple classrooms, and
multiple schools in a district does not equate to the perpupil reduction to the district
budget nor does it allow for reductions of classes or closure of schools in most cases,”
The study recommended
increasing the perpupil
facilities allowance, as well
as mandating that charter
schools have first access to
buying unused public
schools.Scott said in an email. “Now we are suggesting that school districts across the
Commonwealth who are waiting in line for much needed school replacements or major
renovations should have additional competition for the dwindling resources available.”
Richard Stutman, president of the Boston Teachers Union, said charter schools do not
require additional funding and are actually overfunded, because they do not educate
costlier students, such as Englishlanguage learners or special education students.
“The students they educate are on the low cost, so they don’t need as much per
student,” he said, adding that the suggestion that charter schools need more money is
dishonest.
According to the study, charter schools have smaller building and classroom sizes than
their regular public school counterparts. More than half of Massachusetts charter
schools are at least 20 percent smaller — either in terms of the size of classrooms, or
the gross square feet per student.
Additionally, 82 percent of charter schools are on properties that are 20 percent
smaller than the state average.
Kenen said those shortcomings are usually most apparent in a lack of science labs, art
rooms, playgrounds, and sports facilities. For most charter schools, “all the available
resources go into academics,” Kenen said. “Some of the other aspects of the
educational experience are not fully addressed.”
Matthew Wilder, spokesman for Boston Public Schools, said he did not believe the
study’s call for increased funding to charter schools would necessarily hurt district
schools also vying for more resources. Collaborative efforts, he said, could ensure that
all schools in the area benefit from increased funding.
“The mayor has made it very clear that there needs to be a new era of cooperation
between traditional public schools and charter schools,” Wilder said. “We’re past the
time where we can really argue about these things.”
Kevin Andrews, founding headmaster of the Neighborhood House Charter School in
Dorchester, said that after allocations from the state, his school must still pay
$400,000 to $450,000 per year in loans to fund the school’s campus. Those costs are
covered using private funds, he said — but many other charter schools do not have the
same kind of access to outside resources.© 2013 THE NEW YORK TIMES COMPANY
“We’re not asking for the sky. We’re not asking for anything except fairness — and if
you really look at the facts,” Andrews said, “you will clearly see that there is a gap that
needs to be filled for charter schools.”